Prince Harry and his wife Meghan began a new life in Canada last week, having stepped down as senior royals and left the UK. The couple's departure has forced a heated debate on a problem that many say the country is failing to face up to: racism.
People from ethnic minority backgrounds make up 19.5% of the population of England and Wales. But some people who identify with this community say that when they call out their experiences of racism, they are shut down. By white British people.
"The white person in this debate always centers it on themselves," author and broadcaster Afua Hirsch told CNN. "It would make more sense if somebody said: I haven't got a lived experience of racism. I would like to understand your perspective."
From as early as November 2016, Kensington Palace issued statements about the "abuse and harassment" that British media directed at Meghan, noting both the "racial undertones" and the "outright sexism and racism" she experienced as a result. When the Duke and Duchess of Sussex announced their shock decision to scale back their royal duties barely three years later, it was little wonder why.
But many of those who have dared to point out that racism is a factor in the Sussexes' recent move have been publicly slammed for doing so. On the BBC political debate show Question Time, university lecturer Rachel Boyle, who identifies as black, said the UK press "have torn [Meghan] to pieces" because of racism.
Thank you for the support Twitter 💜 I am appalled by the argument presented to me by this man! At no point did I call him racist, I said that his viewpoint is informed by his white privileged position- and he didn’t like it. https://t.co/Du6nAUoS5o— Rachel C. Boyle (@RachelCBoyle1) January 16, 2020
Her claims were deemed as "boring" by white panelist and actor Laurence Fox. He then said that Boyle was "being racist" after she described him as a "white privileged male." The audience applauded Fox, and the pair's altercation trended on Twitter.
Hirsch, a former barrister who is of African heritage, was abused online after writing an opinion piece for the New York Times on the racism directed towards Meghan. She was also berated on TV by Piers Morgan, host of the popular breakfast TV show Good Morning Britain.
"I am often requested to go into spaces where I'm the only person of color on TV debates and primetime shows," Hirsch told CNN, describing the experience as "entertainment" for viewers.
"[They] expect me to single-handedly show them what is racist, prove that racism exists. That in itself is a manifestation of white privilege."
Appearing on the This Morning TV show, lawyer and activist Shola Mos-Shogbamimu was asked to give examples of racism in the UK; she explained that it was "exhausting" having to keep proving that racism exists.
But Hirsch believes it is important to keep educating people.
"People think racism is when somebody has in their mind that they hate people of color. [They] will say, 'I don't have a racist bone in my body,' while perpetrating racist narratives. This is an opportunity to show people what racism can look like."
The musician added that racism in the country had worsened under the leadership of Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who has previously been criticized for making racist remarks.Stormzy's comments were misinterpreted by a number of media outlets who suggested he had said that the UK was 100% racist. Broadcaster ITV News later issued an apology for its characterization of the story, but the incident has added to a simmering debate on race that was already in full force.
Have ITV seen the abuse #Stormzy has taken on Social Media as a direct result of ITV misrepresenting what Stormzy said? Have ITV seen endless Newspaper Headlines copying the misrepresentation of Stormzy by ITV?
ITV smearing #musician 2distract from Tory mess.@itvlondon #racism — Christina (@55krissi55) December 22, 2019
And here it is.
Stormzy is getting flack because he is WRONG. Period. There is a leftist agenda to try to stop criticism of anyone if they have some kind of minority identity. The UK public are sick to the back teeth with this rot. #StormzyIsAMassiveBellend https://t.co/uxPzxsgNrx — BanTheBBC (@BanTheBBC) December 23, 2019
Two people speak out about racism in the same day.
One is black, one is white.
The reactions could not be more different.
Gary Neville praised to the hilt.
Stormzy gets abused. pic.twitter.com/aeyxH98vVC — James Bell (@James_W_Bell) December 23, 2019
Despite this, it was felt the headline at the top of this story on our website and Twitter post did not reflect these comments fully and was therefore amended.
The tweet regarding the quotes was also later removed. We would like to apologise to Stormzy for any misunderstanding. — ITV News (@itvnews) December 22, 2019
Is there racism in football? Is there racism in our society?
Do we need to call it out and stand with those who do?
Definitely, 100%. #ShowRacismTheRedCard — Sadiq Khan (@SadiqKhan) December 22, 2019
'Racism is not a matter of opinion'
The UK is often praised as a melting pot of cultures. But research shows that multiculturalism is now under attack. Omar Khan, director of the race equality think tank Runnymede Trust, points to a report that found 71% of people from ethnic minorities who were surveyed in early 2019 reported having experienced racial discrimination, compared with 58% before Britain's 2016 vote to leave the European Union.
Online racism has more than doubled to 51% since two years before the Brexit vote, according to the survey by Opinium. The same survey found that the number of people from ethnic minority groups reporting rants and negative comments about immigration or racist comments made to sound like jokes rose by about 50%.
Even the United Nations has said more needs to be done about racism in the UK, including Brexit-era hate crimes. "I got more racism last year than in the previous 25 years, all of it online on Twitter," Sunder Katwala, director of think tank British Future, told CNN.
"We should protect free speech, but not racist abuse." Social media squabbles also distract from the real problem. "The racist stereotypes about different ethnic groups are always predictable," Omar Khan said, explaining that the roots of racism in the UK can be traced back to the days of the British Empire. "They are part of our wider intellectual and cultural heritage," he said. "Frankly, it's embarrassing we still don't recognize this, and instead prefer social media or personality spats instead of actually tackling racism and its consequences."
Starling said that an overall lack of diverse representation in influential positions is a major reason why certain perspectives are less accepted.
While diversity in parliament has improved in recent years, in September 2019, just over 8% of members of the House of Commons were from non-white ethnic backgrounds. Representation is not always welcome, though.
Amnesty International's analysis of tweets mentioning female MPs in the lead-up to the 2017 general election found that almost a third of abusive tweets reviewed were targeting one woman: Diane Abbott, the black high-profile shadow home secretary.
British society is known for its traditional "stiff upper lip" and "reserved" attitude, but Starling says it must tackle this issue, regardless of how uncomfortable it might be to do so. "Being called racist indicates that we might be a bad person," he says. "We might hold a bias and that's really scary and very uncomfortable." But uncovering unconscious bias, innate stereotypes about certain groups of people that we are unaware of, is in dire need of discussion, he says.
Someone's lived experience of racism, though, should not be open to debate. "Racism is not a matter of opinion," says Khan, "but of evidence and reality." In fact, like Meghan and Harry, Hirsch says some people subjected to racial discrimination are considering leaving the country too. "I'm not saying people should leave... [But] I don't feel this is a healthy place to be right now."